NewYorkEatsguide

The Bronx neighborhood guide

Restaurants in City Island, The Bronx

City Island has 22 places to eat and drink in the NewYorkEatsguide directory — restaurants (6), bars & pubs (6), delis & sandwiches (4) and seafood (2).

The highest-rated spot right now is Little Greece, at 4.9★ from 184 reviews. The list below ranks every listing in City Island by rating, weighting places with more reviews first.

Open the The Bronx Map

What's in City Island

Top-rated places in City Island

  1. 1

    Little Greece

    Ice Cream & Desserts · 327 City Island Ave

    4.9★ (184)

  2. 2

    City Island Pizza Company

    Restaurants · 273 City Island Ave

    4.9★ (90)

  3. 3

    Little Frida's Eatery

    Restaurants · 415 City Island Ave

    4.9★ (81)

  4. 4

    Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge

    Restaurants · 565 City Island Ave

    4.8★ (11,945)

  5. 5

    Clipper Coffee

    Cafes & Coffee · 274 City Island Ave

    4.8★ (199)

  6. 6

    2 PaiZan's Pizzeria Cucina

    Pizza · 250 City Island Ave

    4.8★ (66)

  7. 7

    ATIK Restaurant

    Restaurants · 555 City Island Ave

    4.7★ (1,409)

  8. 8

    The Black Whale

    Bars & Pubs · 279 City Island Ave

    4.6★ (515)

  9. 9

    Sea Breeze Deli Corp

    Delis & Sandwiches · 325 City Island Ave

    4.6★ (52)

  10. 10

    The Silent Sea

    Bars & Pubs · 634 City Island Ave

    4.6★ (39)

  11. 11

    Fella's Bar & Grill

    Bars & Pubs · 522 City Island Ave

    4.5★ (58)

  12. 12

    Johnny's Reef

    Fast Food · 2 City Island Ave

    4.4★ (9,497)

  13. 13

    City Island Lobster House

    Seafood · 691 Bridge St

    4.4★ (5,705)

  14. 14

    City Island Diner

    Restaurants · 304 City Island Ave

    4.4★ (495)

  15. 15

    Ray's Cafe & Restaurant

    Restaurants · 205 City Island Ave

    4.4★ (90)

  16. 16

    Sammy's Fish Box

    Bars & Pubs · 41 City Island Ave

    4.3★ (10,867)

  17. 17

    Tony's Pier

    Seafood · 1 City Island Ave

    4.3★ (6,091)

  18. 18

    Sea Shore Restaurant

    Bars & Pubs · 591 City Island Ave

    4.3★ (3,826)

  19. 19

    Augie's City Island Deli

    Delis & Sandwiches · 520 City Island Ave

    4.3★ (195)

  20. 20

    Firehouse Deli

    Delis & Sandwiches · 240 City Island Ave

    4.3★ (83)

  21. 21

    Sammy's Smokehouse

    Bars & Pubs · 64 City Island Ave

    4.2★ (3,600)

  22. 22

    City Island Chinese Restaurant

    Delis & Sandwiches · 84-86 City Island Ave

    4.1★ (120)

Popular cuisines

American (2) · Mediterranean (2) · Greek (2) · Mexican (2) · Pizza (2) · Latin American (1) · Sushi (1) · Chinese (1)

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants are in City Island?

NewYorkEatsguide lists 22 restaurants, cafes, bakeries and bars in City Island, the Bronx.

What is the best-rated restaurant in City Island?

Little Greece is currently the top-rated listing in City Island with 4.9 stars from 184 reviews. Other highly rated picks include City Island Pizza Company and Little Frida's Eatery.

What kind of food is City Island known for?

The most common cuisines among City Island listings are American, Mediterranean, Greek, Mexican and Pizza.

Neighborhoods near City Island

The Bronx by category