Brooklyn neighborhood guide

Restaurants in Coney Island, Brooklyn

Coney Island has 26 places to eat and drink in the NewYorkEatsguide directory — restaurants (8), delis & sandwiches (5), fast food (4) and pizza (3).

The highest-rated spot right now is NY Bread Inc, at 4.6★ from 342 reviews. The list below ranks every listing in Coney Island by rating, weighting places with more reviews first.

Open the Brooklyn Map

What's in Coney Island

Restaurants (8)
Delis & Sandwiches (5)
Fast Food (4)
Pizza (3)
Cafes & Coffee (2)
Bars & Pubs (2)
Bakeries (1)
Seafood (1)

Top-rated places in Coney Island

1

NY Bread Inc

Bakeries · 2201 Neptune Ave

4.6★ (342)
2

Anhor Cafe

Restaurants · 2127 Neptune Ave

4.6★ (66)
3

Cyclone Bagels

Cafes & Coffee · 2028 Surf Ave

4.5★ (89)
4

Gargiulo's

Seafood · 2911 W 15th St

4.4★ (1,659)
5

Milk & Honey Cafe

Restaurants · 1515 Surf Ave

4.4★ (344)
6

Pete's Clam Stop

Bars & Pubs · 1320 Surf Ave

4.4★ (141)
7

Neighborhood Gourmet Food

Delis & Sandwiches · 2909 Surf Ave

4.4★ (88)
8

Nathan's Famous

Fast Food · 1310 Surf Ave

4.3★ (15,616)
9

Oriental Palace Kitchen

Restaurants · 3018 Mermaid Ave

4.3★ (477)
10

Pizza On The Run

Delis & Sandwiches · 1627 Mermaid Ave

4.3★ (369)
11

ChowTime

Restaurants · 1418 Mermaid Ave

4.3★ (214)
12

S&A Pizzeria

Fast Food · 2726 Mermaid Ave

4.2★ (166)
13

Pizza On The Run

Pizza · 2914 Stillwell Ave

4.2★ (144)
14

Totonno's

Pizza · 1524 Neptune Ave

4.1★ (906)
15

Gourmet Deli & Grill

Delis & Sandwiches · 2827 Mermaid Ave

4.0★ (26)
16

Mi Candileja

Restaurants · 1509 Mermaid Ave

3.9★ (777)
17

Salt & Sizzle

Bars & Pubs · 1301 Riegelmann Boardwalk

3.9★ (478)
18

Leanly

Delis & Sandwiches · 1627 Mermaid Ave

3.9★ (265)
19

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

Fast Food · 3019 Mermaid Ave

3.8★ (354)
20

Famous Rotisserie And Grill

Restaurants · 1525 Mermaid Ave

3.6★ (61)
21

McDonald's

Cafes & Coffee · 1403 Mermaid Ave

3.5★ (1,980)
22

East Far

Delis & Sandwiches · 2406 Mermaid Ave

3.5★ (163)
23

Kennedy Fried Chicken

Restaurants · 2325 Mermaid Ave

3.5★ (161)
24

Panda

Restaurants · 2807 Mermaid Ave

3.4★ (45)
25

Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · 2124 Mermaid Ave

3.3★ (241)
26

Burger King

Fast Food · 1702 Neptune Ave

3.2★ (380)

Popular cuisines

Chinese (6) · Pizza (5) · American (2) · Middle Eastern (1) · Italian (1) · Dominican (1) · Burger (1)

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants are in Coney Island?

NewYorkEatsguide lists 26 restaurants, cafes, bakeries and bars in Coney Island, Brooklyn.

What is the best-rated restaurant in Coney Island?

NY Bread Inc is currently the top-rated listing in Coney Island with 4.6 stars from 342 reviews. Other highly rated picks include Anhor Cafe and Cyclone Bagels.

What kind of food is Coney Island known for?

The most common cuisines among Coney Island listings are Chinese, Pizza, American, Middle Eastern and Italian.