NewYorkEatsguide

Staten Island neighborhood guide

Restaurants in Eltingville, Staten Island

Eltingville has 28 places to eat and drink in the NewYorkEatsguide directory — delis & sandwiches (14), restaurants (6), bars & pubs (2) and cafes & coffee (2).

The highest-rated spot right now is Island Social, at 4.9★ from 246 reviews. The list below ranks every listing in Eltingville by rating, weighting places with more reviews first.

Open the Staten Island Map

What's in Eltingville

Top-rated places in Eltingville

  1. 1

    Island Social

    Bars & Pubs · 4060 Hylan Blvd

    4.9★ (246)

  2. 2

    Riva Mediterranean & Turkish Cuisine

    Restaurants · 4318 Amboy Rd

    4.8★ (538)

  3. 3

    Ohkami Ramen

    Restaurants · 3827 Richmond Ave

    4.8★ (488)

  4. 4

    Cafe Gianna

    Cafes & Coffee · 4076c Hylan Blvd

    4.8★ (51)

  5. 5

    Pastosa Ravioli of Eltingville

    Delis & Sandwiches · 3817 Richmond Ave

    4.7★ (365)

  6. 6

    Patrizia's of Brooklyn

    Pizza · 4255 Amboy Rd

    4.6★ (2,387)

  7. 7

    Original Giuseppes Pizza

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4300 Amboy Rd

    4.6★ (188)

  8. 8

    Banhmis & Asian Cuisine

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4018 Hylan Blvd

    4.6★ (164)

  9. 9

    Andrew's Diner

    Restaurants · 4160 Hylan Blvd

    4.5★ (1,429)

  10. 10

    Trattoria Toscana

    Restaurants · 4200 Hylan Blvd

    4.5★ (403)

  11. 11

    Hong Kong Kei One

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4207 Hylan Blvd

    4.5★ (280)

  12. 12

    Good Taste

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4215 Hylan Blvd

    4.5★ (99)

  13. 13

    Portobello Cafe

    Cafes & Coffee · 4221 Hylan Blvd

    4.4★ (554)

  14. 14

    Pacific Kitchen

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4255 Amboy Rd

    4.4★ (152)

  15. 15

    Cucumber Sushi & Salad Bar on Hylan

    Bars & Pubs · 4215c Hylan Blvd

    4.4★ (140)

  16. 16

    Nature's Grill Staten Island

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4115 Hylan Blvd

    4.4★ (88)

  17. 17

    Kingdom Pizza

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4350 Amboy Rd

    4.3★ (210)

  18. 18

    Subway

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4348B Amboy Rd

    4.3★ (127)

  19. 19

    Frank And Danny's

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4369 Amboy Rd

    4.2★ (245)

  20. 20

    Avocado Sushi

    Seafood · 4342 Amboy Rd

    4.1★ (216)

  21. 21

    Pizza Mia Eltingville (Formerly Dough)

    Delis & Sandwiches · 3831 Richmond Ave

    4.1★ (129)

  22. 22

    Richmond Bagels

    Delis & Sandwiches · Parking lot

    4.1★ (52)

  23. 23

    China Chalet

    Restaurants · 4326 Amboy Rd

    4.0★ (195)

  24. 24

    Big Al's Pizza

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4069 Hylan Blvd

    4.0★ (102)

  25. 25

    Wendy's

    Fast Food · 25 Putnam St

    3.7★ (934)

  26. 26

    Burger King

    Fast Food · 3901 Richmond Ave

    3.5★ (469)

  27. 27

    Empire Szechuan

    Restaurants · 4373 Amboy Rd

    3.5★ (150)

  28. 28

    East Sushi

    Delis & Sandwiches · 4371 Amboy Rd

    3.4★ (47)

Popular cuisines

Pizza (6) · Italian (5) · Chinese (5) · Burger (3) · Sushi (3) · Japanese (2) · American (1) · Turkish (1)

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants are in Eltingville?

NewYorkEatsguide lists 28 restaurants, cafes, bakeries and bars in Eltingville, Staten Island.

What is the best-rated restaurant in Eltingville?

Island Social is currently the top-rated listing in Eltingville with 4.9 stars from 246 reviews. Other highly rated picks include Riva Mediterranean & Turkish Cuisine and Ohkami Ramen.

What kind of food is Eltingville known for?

The most common cuisines among Eltingville listings are Pizza, Italian, Chinese, Burger and Sushi.

Neighborhoods near Eltingville

Staten Island by category