NewYorkEatsguide

Staten Island neighborhood guide

Restaurants in Tompkinsville, Staten Island

Tompkinsville has 13 places to eat and drink in the NewYorkEatsguide directory — restaurants (7), delis & sandwiches (4), cafes & coffee (1) and pizza (1).

The highest-rated spot right now is La Plaza Mexican Deli, at 4.8★ from 40 reviews. The list below ranks every listing in Tompkinsville by rating, weighting places with more reviews first.

Open the Staten Island Map

What's in Tompkinsville

Top-rated places in Tompkinsville

  1. 1

    La Plaza Mexican Deli

    Delis & Sandwiches · 400 Victory Blvd

    4.8★ (40)

  2. 2

    Amira Cafe and Bistro

    Cafes & Coffee · 11 Cebra Ave

    4.8★ (33)

  3. 3

    family cafe and restaurant

    Restaurants · 324 Victory Blvd

    4.8★ (27)

  4. 4

    New Asha Sri Lanka Restaurant

    Restaurants · 322 Victory Blvd

    4.7★ (460)

  5. 5

    Holland Bay Restaurant

    Restaurants · 78 Victory Blvd

    4.5★ (169)

  6. 6

    Los Pastorcitos G's

    Delis & Sandwiches · 110 Victory Blvd

    4.4★ (123)

  7. 7

    Max Ceylon Curry restaurant

    Restaurants · 324 Victory Blvd

    4.3★ (142)

  8. 8

    Mi Armadillo Mexican Taqueria

    Restaurants · 12 Cebra Ave

    4.3★ (51)

  9. 9

    Mixteca Poblana

    Restaurants · 104 Victory Blvd

    4.2★ (207)

  10. 10

    Morelos Mexican Restaurant & Deli

    Delis & Sandwiches · 6 Cebra Ave

    4.0★ (102)

  11. 11

    My Family Pizza

    Pizza · 340 Victory Blvd

    4.0★ (92)

  12. 12

    Famous New York Pizza

    Delis & Sandwiches · 430 Jersey St

    3.9★ (254)

  13. 13

    Cinderellas Mexican Restaurant

    Restaurants · 108 Victory Blvd

    3.9★ (207)

Popular cuisines

Mexican (6) · Pizza (2) · Caribbean (1) · Jamaican (1) · Taco (1) · Italian (1)

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants are in Tompkinsville?

NewYorkEatsguide lists 13 restaurants, cafes, bakeries and bars in Tompkinsville, Staten Island.

What is the best-rated restaurant in Tompkinsville?

La Plaza Mexican Deli is currently the top-rated listing in Tompkinsville with 4.8 stars from 40 reviews. Other highly rated picks include Amira Cafe and Bistro and family cafe and restaurant.

What kind of food is Tompkinsville known for?

The most common cuisines among Tompkinsville listings are Mexican, Pizza, Caribbean, Jamaican and Taco.

Neighborhoods near Tompkinsville

Staten Island by category