Guides
Where to Find Authentic Neapolitan Pizza in Brooklyn
The best authentic Neapolitan pizza in Brooklyn — wood-fired, blistered, and served the way it's meant to be across the borough.
Authentic Neapolitan pizza in Brooklyn is a specific thing. It’s a soft, blistered pizza with a puffy cornicione, a thin wet center, mozzarella that’s been imported or made that morning, and a wood-fired oven that runs at nearly 900 degrees. It’s not a New York slice, and it’s not trying to be one.
What makes a Neapolitan pizza actually Neapolitan
The Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana keeps a rulebook — 00 flour, San Marzano tomatoes, fior di latte or bufala mozzarella, sea salt, extra-virgin olive oil, and a wood-fired oven at around 485°C for 60 to 90 seconds. The result is a pie you eat with a knife and fork because the center is deliberately underdone. If a Neapolitan-style pizza doesn’t leave a soft, slightly wet middle, it’s been overcooked or the oven wasn’t hot enough. Neither is a small mistake.
The best Neapolitan pizza in Brooklyn right now
Roberta’s in Bushwick is the obvious starting point, and reputation aside, the Margherita there still holds up. The Bee Sting — soppressata, chili, honey — is the outlier order that ruined honey pizza for a generation, and it’s better here than anywhere trying to copy it. The wait can be long. Go on a Tuesday.
Lucali on Henry Street in Carroll Gardens is the other name that gets brought up, and the wait there is worse — no reservations, sometimes three hours in line — but the pizza is the point. The crust is thinner than a strict Neapolitan, the dough is cold-fermented longer, and the whole operation runs on Mark Iacono’s rhythm. Bring wine (it’s BYOB) and don’t be in a rush.
Neapolitan spots that don’t require the line
If you want the pizza without the pilgrimage, Ops in Bushwick is the answer. They mill their own flour, the sourdough is fermented for two days, and a Margherita there rivals anything at the marquee names. Same for La Villetta in Ditmas Park — a smaller, quieter spot with a proper wood oven and a Margherita di Bufala that eats better than half of Manhattan’s Italian scene.
Wood-fired variations worth trying
Wood-fired doesn’t automatically mean Neapolitan, but the two often overlap. Speedy Romeo in Clinton Hill does a Neapolitan-ish crust with more creative toppings — the St. Louie with candied bacon has a following. Emmy Squared, from the Emily team, does a Detroit-style square with a wood-fired base that’s a different thing entirely, but it’s on the same tour route if you’re chasing pies across Brooklyn. Try both. They’re 12 minutes apart on the G.
How to order at a Neapolitan pizza shop
A few habits to look like you know what you’re doing. Order Margherita first — it’s the test. If the Margherita is right, everything else on the menu is probably right too. Don’t ask for pepperoni; the American pepperoni you want is a different meat than what the word means in Italian, and Neapolitan spots will hand you soppressata or salame. Don’t ask for garlic knots. This is not that kind of pizza.
Neapolitan pizza vs New York slice
The two aren’t in competition. A New York slice is fast food, meant to be folded and eaten walking. A Neapolitan pizza is a sit-down meal, meant to be shared and eaten with a fork. Both are Brooklyn food traditions and both are worth understanding on their own terms. If you’re doing a full pizza tour of the borough, both belong on the list.
What to drink with it
The classic pairing is Peroni or a Nastro Azzurro, but a lighter red like a Chianti or Aglianico goes better with a Margherita than any beer. If it’s summer, order a bottle of Falanghina — it’s the wine everyone in Naples drinks with pizza. Skip the craft cocktails at pizza places; the ovens are too hot and the ice is too fresh, and no one is doing their best work at a pizza bar.
Every wood-fired spot mentioned above is on the NewYorkEatsguide map, and if you’re building a bigger Brooklyn eating day, our Bushwick coffee shops guide covers the walk between Roberta’s and Ops.
More NYC food guides
Keep exploring the city’s food scene:
