Guides
Where to Eat in NYC: 55 Places Worth Building a Day Around
Where to eat in NYC — 55 places worth building a day around, sorted by craving. Pizza, bagels, tacos, ramen, barbecue, and the desserts to end on.
New York doesn’t have a best restaurant. It has hundreds of places that are the best at exactly one thing, and the skill is knowing which craving points where. This list is built by craving, not by ranking or neighborhood. Find what you want to eat, pick the spot, and let the subway sort out the rest.
Quick note: this city churns through restaurants faster than almost anywhere on earth. Rents rise, leases end, chefs move. Confirm a place is still standing before you plan a whole afternoon around it.
The best pizza in NYC by the whole pie
New Yorkers are exhausting about pizza and mostly right to be. The split is between the coal and wood-fired whole-pie places, which are destinations, and the corner slice joints, which are infrastructure.
Motorino pies come out with black blisters along the rim — what you want, and what most places undercook past. Their Brussels sprout pizza is the one that surprises people. Roberta’s was born in a Bushwick warehouse district before anyone was going to Bushwick, and it still has the garden and the radio booth. John’s of Bleecker Street does no slices, never has, never will — coal-oven pies with a thin, smoke-marked crust. Lucali is candlelit, no reservations, still the answer for a certain kind of night. And Artichoke Basille’s is the slice that ends nights — artichoke hearts and spinach floating in cream under mozzarella.
The best bagels in NYC that actually fight you back
A real bagel is boiled first, then baked, and it should fight you a little. Anything soft all the way through is bread with a hole in it.
Russ & Daughters has been open since 1914 — the bagel itself is solid rather than transcendent, so treat it as a delivery system for the fish. Ess-A-Bagel hand-rolls, boils properly, and stuffs so aggressively the top half slides off before you’re outside. Absolute, Murray’s, and Hudson are the other members of the hand-rolled club — same texture: crust with actual resistance, dense chewy interior.
The best tacos in NYC and where to find real Mexican
Manhattan spent years being bad at this and then quietly stopped being bad at it.
Los Tacos No. 1 is the best tacos in Manhattan and the line moves faster than it looks — ask for the especial, a quesadilla crisped on the plancha. Los Mariscos sits right next door and gets a fraction of the attention, which is a mistake — fried fish tacos, shrimp, ceviche. Otto’s Tacos presses tortillas that hit the griddle while you watch. Empellón is Alex Stupak’s project — the salsas are the real event.
Burgers and sandwiches that hold their spot
Minetta Tavern Black Label Burger is closer to a steak that changed shape than a burger — brisket, short rib, skirt steak, and dry-aged ribeye blended. Shake Shack — skip the plain cheeseburger and order the Shack Stack, which sets a fried cheese-filled portobello on top of a beef patty. Num Pang does Cambodian-influenced sandwiches on a short baguette; the Duroc pulled pork is the order.
Taim makes the best falafel in the city and it isn’t a close race — green falafel packed with parsley, mint, and cilantro. Katz’s Delicatessen has hand-cut pastrami since 1888 — take the ticket at the door, hand it directly to a carver, slip him a couple of bucks. Mile End Deli does Montreal smoked meat — pastrami’s smokier and more peppered relative — on rye with mustard and nothing else.
Ramen counters that are worth the wait
Ivan Ramen — Ivan Orkin moved to Tokyo, opened a shop, beat the local competition, and came home to do it again. The Triple Pork Triple Garlic Mazemen has no broth at all. Ippudo is the bowl that taught most Americans what ramen actually is. Chuko Ramen in Brooklyn does the surprise vegetarian bowl of the category, built on mushroom and kombu with real weight to it.
The city’s one great barbecue spot
New York has no business being good at this and one place is anyway.
Hometown Bar-B-Que in Red Hook is the best barbecue in the city by a comfortable margin — the beef rib is a single enormous bone. Mighty Quinn’s brisket stays moist because they rest it properly. Blue Smoke does barbecue with hospitality-industry service, which is a strange combination that works.
Food carts and trucks that still hold their corner
The Halal Guys — a yellow cart that’s held the same corner for over 30 years and still draws a line at 2am. Chicken or lamb over yellow rice with shredded lettuce, pita, and the white sauce. Wafels & Dinges — Liège waffles made from dough rather than batter, studded with pearl sugar that caramelizes hard against the iron.
Cookies, cupcakes, and the sugar payoff
Levain Bakery is the best cookie in New York and it’s not particularly close — six ounces each, crackly outside, barely set in the middle. Sugar Sweet Sunshine does cupcakes for around $3, which reads like a pricing error in Manhattan. Two Little Red Hens does the red velvet properly tangy and the Brooklyn blackout cake dense, dark, and unapologetic.
Ice cream and gelato worth an extra walk
Ample Hills Creamery — Ooey Gooey Butter Cake folds chunks of St. Louis butter cake into vanilla and converts skeptics on the first spoon. Il Laboratorio del Gelato has developed over 200 flavors and rotates 40 at a time — dark chocolate is the benchmark. Morgenstern’s is an old-fashioned parlor with a laboratory habit — Raw Milk, Salt and Pepper Pinenut, Angel Food Vanilla.
The big nights out
Blue Hill at Stone Barns — an hour north of the city on a working farm, where the menu is whatever the fields and greenhouses produced that week. Gramercy Tavern never started coasting — tasting menu in back, walk-in tavern in front. Eleven Madison Park — three Michelin stars, tasting menu only, entirely plant-based since 2021. Le Coucou is Daniel Rose’s upscale French, candlelit and high-ceilinged in a way that makes everyone look better.
Everything else worth planning around
Xi’an Famous Foods — hand-pulled Shaanxi noodles, cumin lamb the flagship. Souvlaki GR — chicken souvlaki in pita with tzatziki. Crif Dogs — deep-fried hot dogs with a real snap. Clinton St. Baking Company — the best pancakes I’ve eaten anywhere. Doughnut Plant — the PB and J is a square yeast doughnut filled with real jam. Vanessa’s Dumplings — four fried pork and chive dumplings for a couple of dollars, still the best cheap eat in Manhattan.
More NYC food guides
Keep exploring the city’s food scene:
