NewYorkEatsguide

Staten Island neighborhood guide

Restaurants in Tottenville, Staten Island

Tottenville has 25 places to eat and drink in the NewYorkEatsguide directory — delis & sandwiches (10), cafes & coffee (5), restaurants (5) and bars & pubs (2).

The highest-rated spot right now is Deluca's Italian Restaurant, at 4.6★ from 757 reviews. The list below ranks every listing in Tottenville by rating, weighting places with more reviews first.

Open the Staten Island Map

What's in Tottenville

Top-rated places in Tottenville

  1. 1

    Deluca's Italian Restaurant

    Cafes & Coffee · 7324 Amboy Rd

    4.6★ (757)

  2. 2

    Mangia

    Delis & Sandwiches · 7517 Amboy Rd

    4.6★ (258)

  3. 3

    Baya Bar - Acai & Smoothie Shop

    Health & Juice · 6833 Amboy Rd

    4.6★ (199)

  4. 4

    Vesuvio Trattoria & Pizzeria

    Delis & Sandwiches · 7423 Amboy Rd

    4.6★ (171)

  5. 5

    Dani's Italian Bistro

    Restaurants · 7331 Amboy Rd

    4.6★ (111)

  6. 6

    Tres Amigos Taqueria & Restaurant

    Restaurants · 7528 Amboy Rd

    4.5★ (320)

  7. 7

    Mikey Bagels

    Bakeries · 7420 Amboy Rd

    4.5★ (224)

  8. 8

    Tropical Smoothie Cafe

    Cafes & Coffee · 7001 Amboy Rd

    4.5★ (113)

  9. 9

    Kim's Island

    Delis & Sandwiches · 175 Main St

    4.5★ (102)

  10. 10

    Rocky's Pizza Bar

    Bars & Pubs · 7339 Amboy Rd

    4.5★ (52)

  11. 11

    Towne Deli & Pizzeria

    Delis & Sandwiches · 5373 Arthur Kill Rd

    4.4★ (760)

  12. 12

    Chef Hong II

    Delis & Sandwiches · 7226 Amboy Rd

    4.3★ (138)

  13. 13

    W's Bar And Grill

    Bars & Pubs · 7001 Amboy Rd

    4.3★ (129)

  14. 14

    Villa Monte Pizzeria South

    Delis & Sandwiches · 7001 Amboy Rd

    4.2★ (255)

  15. 15

    Coral Bay Cafe

    Restaurants · 722 Rockaway St

    4.2★ (252)

  16. 16

    Fina's Farmhouse

    Cafes & Coffee · 20 Ellis St

    4.2★ (249)

  17. 17

    Taqueria Oaxaca

    Delis & Sandwiches · 167 Main St

    4.2★ (185)

  18. 18

    Nonna's Pizza Tottenville

    Pizza · 311 Page Ave

    4.2★ (82)

  19. 19

    Mizu Hibachi & Steak House

    Cafes & Coffee · 240 Page Ave

    4.0★ (230)

  20. 20

    Cracker Barrel Deli

    Delis & Sandwiches · 180 Main St

    4.0★ (120)

  21. 21

    Subway

    Delis & Sandwiches · 303 A Page Ave

    4.0★ (99)

  22. 22

    McDonald's

    Cafes & Coffee · 260 Page Ave

    3.3★ (910)

  23. 23

    Gnocchi On The GO

    Restaurants · 7507 Amboy Rd

    4.7★ (13)

  24. 24

    Peking Taste

    Restaurants · 240 Page Ave

    4.4★ (14)

  25. 25

    South Shore Deli And Convenient

    Delis & Sandwiches · 7344 Amboy Rd

    3.9★ (20)

Popular cuisines

Italian (7) · Pizza (6) · Chinese (3) · Mexican (2) · Japanese (1) · Sushi (1) · Burger (1)

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants are in Tottenville?

NewYorkEatsguide lists 25 restaurants, cafes, bakeries and bars in Tottenville, Staten Island.

What is the best-rated restaurant in Tottenville?

Deluca's Italian Restaurant is currently the top-rated listing in Tottenville with 4.6 stars from 757 reviews. Other highly rated picks include Mangia and Baya Bar - Acai & Smoothie Shop.

What kind of food is Tottenville known for?

The most common cuisines among Tottenville listings are Italian, Pizza, Chinese, Mexican and Japanese.

Neighborhoods near Tottenville

Staten Island by category